Elyse Bauer is surprised when she receives a mysterious valentine card invite. She hasn’t been out on a date in months, but she’s intrigued enough to find out who her secret admirer might be. So she follows the instructions on the card in a precise manner and hopes that this isn’t the worst Valentine’s Day date ever. But she’s in for the shock of her life when she shows up to find the one man she’s had the biggest crush on for years, Brody Kaplan, her brother’s best friend.
Brody Kaplan has tried to love his best friend’s older sister from afar, but he’s failing miserably. Unable to stand the thought of watching her enter into another relationship with a man that isn’t him, he decides to make his move. He knows how much Elyse Bauer loves Valentine’s Day and he knows it’s the perfect day to ask her to be his forever.